Game changer or not? A year of Trump’s Afghan plan


WASHINGTON, Aug 19, 2018 (BSS/AFP) – A year since President Donald Trump
unveiled his strategy for Afghanistan, a fresh wave of violence and bloodshed
has assailed the war-torn nation and overshadowed some small glimmers of

Each successful attack represents a massive setback not just for the
Afghanistan government, which is pushing for peace talks with the Taliban,
but also for the Pentagon, where officials insist things are finally

In just the last few days, the Taliban and the Islamic State group have
unleashed a series of deadly operations where civilians have borne the brunt
of the bloodshed, including an IS attack inside a school that killed dozens
of students.

Before that, Taliban militants launched a high-profile attack on the
strategic city of Ghazni, forcing US-backed security forces to struggle for
days to repel them, and challenging the Pentagon narrative that the Taliban
is struggling to effectively target larger cities.

Such headlines are surely not what Trump envisioned when on August 21 last
year he announced that — despite his instinct to pull out — he was doubling
down on the US commitment to Afghanistan and indefinitely prolonging
America’s longest war.

Fed up with President Barack Obama’s notion that America could somehow pull
out of Afghanistan without leaving a security vacuum, military brass welcomed
Trump’s decision to deploy thousands of additional US troops, loosen rules of
engagement and cancel the promise of a timetabled withdrawal.

“The consequences of a rapid exit are both predictable and unacceptable,”
Trump said as he revealed his strategy, which also sought to pressure
Pakistan do more to tackle the Taliban.

– Looking bleak –

Just months later, the top US commander in Afghanistan, General John
Nicholson, claimed the war had “turned the corner” and predicted the Afghan
security forces would expand government control of the population from about
64 percent now to 80 percent over two years.

But according to a US government watchdog, the percentage of people under
government control has only risen to 65 percent, with insurgent groups
holding steady.

“We’ve turned so many corners in Afghanistan that we’ve probably made
multiple circles,” Bill Roggio, an Afghanistan expert and senior fellow at
the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, told AFP.

“Things look pretty bleak,” he said.

“Without a US presence in Afghanistan you would quickly see large areas of
the country… fall under the control of the Taliban,” he added, pointing to
the horrendous casualty rates and other problems that have beset the Afghan
security forces.

A core part of Trump’s Afghanistan plan was to force the Taliban to the
negotiating table and to support peace talks between Kabul and the

An unprecedented country-wide ceasefire between the Taliban and government
forces in June gave some relief to civilians and sparked hopes the truce
could clear the way for talks to end the war.

– Game changer –

Alice Wells, the senior official for the State Department’s Bureau of South
and Central Asia Affairs, reportedly met with Taliban officials last month in

And on a visit to Kabul last month, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said
there was now hope for peace talks between the Afghan government and the

“Many of the Taliban now see that they can’t win on the ground militarily.
That’s very deeply connected to President Trump’s strategy,” Pompeo said.

US-backed Afghan President Ashraf Ghani hailed Trump’s strategy as a “game

However, the recent attacks have led many to question how such negotiations
could move ahead.

Observers have suggested the Taliban may be trying to strengthen their
position before any potential talks.

“This is what we’ve seen before (in) insurgencies, when there’s going to be
a negotiation or a cease-fire, trying to up the ante,” Defense Secretary Jim
Mattis said Thursday.

White House spokeswoman Sarah Sanders said the US remains committed to
finding a political solution to end the Afghanistan conflict.

“We’re exploring all avenues for dialogue in close coordination with the
Afghan government, and we’re going to continue to do that,” she said.

Still, amid the chaos, one sign of progress is that the Taliban have been
unable to hold cities they’ve invaded for more than just a few days at a

But signs are emerging that Trump is growing frustrated with the pace of
progress in Afghanistan, where the US taxpayer has already spent more than $1
trillion and American soldiers are still dying.

NBC News reported Friday the president is showing fresh interest in a
proposal by Eric Prince, the former head of a controversial private military
firm once known as Blackwater.

His idea, loathed by the Pentagon, would essentially privatize the Afghan
war by replacing most US troops there with private contractors.

Currently, about 14,000 US troops are in Afghanistan, providing the main
component of the NATO mission to support and train local forces.