India, lynchings and WhatsApp


NEW DELHI, July 20, 2018 (BSS/AFP) – WhatsApp said Friday that it is
restricting the ability of users in India to forward content, the latest
attempt to curb mob violence sparked by rumours spread through the hugely
popular app.

Crazed mobs in India have killed 21 people in the last two months over
unfounded allegations forwarded on WhatsApp.

Here is a look at what sparked the wave of lynchings, and what has been
done so far:

– Mob rule –

India, a nation of 1.25 billion people, is no stranger to mob violence,
with well-documented cases of crowds turning on victims for every manner of
transgression, real or imagined.

But the spread of smartphones — there are a billion plus handsets, and
data is cheap — to even the most remote corners has enabled rumours to be
shared at lightning speed.

In recent years, for example, there has been an escalation in “cow
vigilantism” — Hindu extremists murdering Muslims and thrashing low-caste
Dalits accused of killing cows or eating beef.

Many of the victims in other vigilante killings, such as those over child
kidnapping rumours, are targeted because they are outsiders.

Victims have included homeless people, a transgender woman, two picnic
goers, an elderly woman handing out chocolates to children and a 27-year-old
software engineer.

– A rumour is born –

The rumour blamed for many of the recent incidents emerged over a year
ago in eastern India, claiming strangers were sedating and abducting

Seven people were killed there in two attacks in as many days.

In February this year, the rumours resurfaced 1,000 miles away in western
India, and reached the south by May. It was often accompanied by a grainy
video purporting to show men on motorbikes stealing kids.

The footage was in fact from a Pakistani public safety film. Other images
supposedly showing dead Indian children with their organs stolen were in
reality of Syrians killed in a gas attack.

– Police powerless –

Indian police say there is no substance to the rumours.

Authorities have rounded up suspects and formed patrols, driving village
to village to quash the rumours. In some areas, travelling musicians sing
about the scourge of fake news.

Authorities in some states shut down internet access in a desperate
effort to stop the hoax from spreading.

But the campaigns had limited effect. In one instance, an official
“rumour buster” was himself beaten to death.

India’s Supreme Court told the government this week to make a new law to
rein in “mobocracy”.

– Legal action –

Earlier this month, the Indian government turned its fire on WhatsApp,
calling for the firm to take “immediate action”.

WhatsApp said it was “horrified” by the lynchings, and announced new
features to help users identify messages that have been forwarded.

The Facebook-owned firm ran full-page adverts in Indian newspapers
offering tips to its 200 million users in the country to separate fact from

But on Thursday the government again let loose, threatening legal action
this time.

WhatsApp responded the next day, saying it would test limiting the
ability to forward content and cap at five the number of contacts or groups
that messages can be transferred to.

However, it rejected government demands to enable the tracing of
messages, saying communications on the app would stay “end-to-end encrypted”.