Canada appeals court upholds landmark tobacco ruling
MONTREAL, March 2, 2019 (BSS/AFP) – Quebec’s appeals court on Friday upheld
a historic ruling ordering three tobacco firms to pay Can$15.5 billion
(US$11.6 billion) to smokers in the Canadian province who claimed they were
never warned about the health risks associated with smoking.
Imperial Tobacco Canada, a subsidiary of British American Tobacco, Rothmans
Benson & Hedges and JTI-MacDonald have one month to launch an eventual appeal
before Canada’s Supreme Court.
In June 2015, the Superior Court of Quebec ruled that the three companies
should pay the whopping amount to tens of thousands of smokers suffering from
emphysema, lung cancer or throat cancer.
According to media reports, accruing interest will bring the final amount
to more than Can$17 billion.
The two class action lawsuits behind the award, which were originally filed
in 1998, affected nearly one million smokers or ex-smokers, some of whom had
been consuming tobacco since the 1960s. The trial only began in March 2012.
“We are disappointed with today’s decision,” Imperial Tobacco Canada
spokesman Eric Gagnon told reporters. “As the ruling in the lower court
showed, Canadian consumers know the risks associated with tobacco use. We
should not be held responsible.”
Lawyers for the plaintiffs meanwhile celebrated the “historic” ruling,
going so far as to call it a “masterpiece.”
“The ruling reached the same conclusions as did the lower court, solidifies
them and confirms that the companies conspired for 50 years to lie to the
public,” one of the attorneys, Andre L’Esperance, told journalists.
“This is a total victory, on all fronts,” added his colleague Philippe
The lower court had ruled that the companies failed in their general duty
“not to cause injury to another person” and to inform their customers of the
risks associated with their products.